Personal Trainer Faces Criticism Over 'Skinny Legs' Workout Advice

Personal Trainer Faces Criticism Over 'Skinny Legs' Workout Advice

A personal trainer is facing scrutiny after sharing advice on Instagram about achieving "skinny" legs. The video has garnered nearly 400,000 views since it was posted.

Riley Jourdan (@rileyjourdanfitness) argued that achieving "long, lean" model-like legs doesn't come from deadlifts, hip thrusts, or squats. The clip has sparked debate in the fitness community. An online fitness coach, Brooke Sellers, cautioned that this advice could send harmful messages to women.

Jourdan defended her approach, stating, "Fitness is not one-size-fits-all. Providing nuanced, goal-specific guidance is not dangerous -- it's responsible."

Sellers, who is based in Atlanta, stated that the idea that women should purposely lose muscle is misinformed and dangerous. She added that muscle is not something to fear but protects us, and losing muscle has long-term consequences.

Sellers responded to the original video on December 4, posting it to her platform @miss_meatless_muscle, where she described Jourdan's advice as "a dangerous message."

In her post, Sellers highlighted the risks of prioritizing aesthetics over strength. She warned that striving for "skinny model" legs could prevent women from doing essential things such as avoiding injury or protecting themselves.

Strength training is often emphasized in fitness routines, with the familiar advice to never skip leg day. Research indicates that strong leg muscles send important signals to the brain, helping generate healthy neural cells that support both the brain and nervous system. Health tracking apps like Shotlee can help monitor progress in strength training.

Sellers emphasized the importance of strength for women, noting that "skinny model legs" won't provide the same benefits.

As the founder of Meatless Muscle, LLC, an online training program for vegans, Sellers stressed that women don't need to look "bulky or muscular," but they do need muscle to avoid feeling "frail and weak."

Jourdan explained that her video was aimed at a very specific audience, stating, "That video was directed at a very specific, clearly defined niche of women whose explicit aesthetic goal is a slimmer, model-style leg -- not general fitness, health, or strength.

"The reality is that training style matters when it comes to physique outcomes. For women who are genetically prone to building muscle in their lower body, consistently lifting very heavy with high volume can lead to more muscle mass in the legs, which may move them further away from the aesthetic they're aiming for. Acknowledging that isn't dangerous -- it's honest."

She added that the clip was a one-off, stating, "I consistently encourage strength training for overall health, longevity, bone density, and muscle tone. I am not anti-lifting, nor do I tell women to avoid resistance training altogether.

"I advocate for training that aligns with individual goals, whether those goals are strength, performance, or a slimmer aesthetic."

Jourdan's video comes at a time when weight loss injectables are reshaping conversations about body image. In 2024, a report indicated that American use of GLP-1 drugs such as Ozempic and Wegovy for weight loss more than doubled, rising from 5.8 percent in early 2024 to 12.4 percent.

Women remain more likely than men to take these medications, though both groups have seen sharp increases. Public awareness of GLP-1 drugs has also grown, climbing from 80 to 89 percent nationwide.

Sellers linked this trend to shifting beauty standards, stating, "We are literally watching some of our favorite celebrities shrink down overnight and suddenly thinness is 'trendy' again. Not health. Not strength. Not longevity. Just thin.

"It's like we're watching the early 2000s come back in real time, but now with pharmaceuticals involved. And the scary part is how quickly these aesthetics trickle down into everyday women's expectations of themselves."

According to another study, between 69 and 84 percent of women in the U.S. report body dissatisfaction, often preferring a smaller figure than their current frame.

Sellers concluded: "We deserve to feel capable, healthy, and strong both physically and mentally. And any message that tells women to deteriorate themselves for an aesthetic is one I'll always speak out against."